Oct. 29, 2026 Updates


For the unofficial Jeffrey Sachs fan club, First - Jeffrey on Judging Freedom, on the settler-colony election and Europe's idiotic prepping the citizens for war; Second - Jeffrey meets Ian Proud in London, then a bit on the 8th Gas Exporting Countries Forum (the sensible countries).

Prof. Jeffrey Sachs: The Future of Netanyahu !?! - Judge Napolitano - Judging Freedom Oct 28, 2026

JUDGE- Hi everyone, Judge Andrew Napolitano here for Judging Freedom. Today is Wednesday, October 28th, 2026. Professor Jeffrey Sachs joins us now.
Professor Sachs, as always, thank you very much for your time. Professor Sachs, does it really matter for the world, for the victims of the Zionist expansion, who the Israeli prime minister is?

SACHS- I think it does. Netanyahu is especially pernicious and dangerous and his two major colleagues in the mass murder of recent years Ben-Gvir and Smotrich make a difference. If they are in power, disasters will continue. If they are shoved from power, as they should be and may well be as a result of this election, at least there's a chance to do something better. So my answer is yes, it does make a difference, we have to show Netanyahu the door. The Israelis have voted. They have voted against him, though given the nature of Israel's system, he's fighting to continue, but I think there's a good chance that he's on his way out. For us in the United States, just to add Netanyahu is a disaster and has been a disaster for 30 years. The fact that our President doubled down on support for him in the last three days is just another example of how President Trump repudiated his own campaign promises and his own base in the last couple of years to support these extremists in Israel.

JUDGE- Well, Netanyahu's coalition shrank dramatically. Am I right now? He has 68 votes from this election. He'll have 52 or three. That is a significant reduction. I don't know.

SACHS- And then the most important point he went from majority to below a majority. So he does not have a basis for governing. That's the key. the issue is, which makes this very interesting, is that the Palestinian Arab population, the citizens of Israel, constitute 2 million people against the 8 million Israeli Jews in a population overall of 10 million people.

JUDGE- Right?

SACHS- So the Palestinians account for about 20% of the citizenship of Israel. Incidentally, let's remember that if you take Israel, and all of the Palestinian territories, Gaza, the West Bank, and East Jerusalem, then it's not 20%, it's 50%. There are roughly 8 million Palestinian Arabs and 8 million Israeli Jews. But within this voting population, the Arabs are about 20% maybe a smidgen below 20%. They voted in huge proportions yesterday in the election. The turnout is estimated to be between 75 and 80%. And they carried it seems, around 20 of the 120 seats of the Knesset, the Israeli parliament.

So what happened is Netanyahu lost his majority. The opponents among the Israeli Jewish parties are slightly behind Netanyahu's count, but neither the Netanyahu side nor the Jewish opposition side (or the Israeli Jewish opposition side) has a majority. And the swing votes are the Arab parties which of course oppose Netanyahu. And this is the very interesting thing, Judge, which is that if this were a normal country, which it is not, unfortunately, but if this were a normal country the opposition Jewish parties would align with the opposition Arab parties and there would be a very significant majority in the parliament and they'd form the next government. But Israel being what it is, which is not a healthy society, but a racist society that also tips over to mass murder, the opposition parties to Netanyahu promised before the election, we will not deal with the Arab parties. God forbid the Arab parties are citizens together with them in one country. God forbid they should deal with them. But if they choose now to deal with them, then they can govern. Then Netanyahu is shown the door, and we have a chance for something better. I'm not giving up on that. In a parliamentary system, there are two ways that that can happen.

One is that they actually form a coalition government. That means that there would be ministers in the cabinet from the Arab parties.

Ah, sad to say, that's quite unlikely to happen because of this underlying racism. But what is another possibility in a parliamentary system is that the opposition today governs with what's called the support of the Arab parties which means that the Arab parties don't enter the cabinet but they support today's opposition to become the government by providing the votes on essential legislation like the national budget. If they can't figure this out, my god, this is really amazing.

Well, [what] they have to do to get rid of that monster is to say, "Okay, we need Netanyahu out. He has been a misery for Israel and we will welcome the support of the Arab parties for that. We will be a minority government but we will govern with the support of the Arab parties and we can be, in that way a stable government, with Netanyahu shown the door." That would be wonderful. Now there's just to say, there's one more option being widely discussed which I don't like as much, but it would also not be the worst of the outcomes and that is that part of Netanyahu's coalition and the opposition parties among the Jewish parties the Zionist parties would form a unity government. But on the condition that Netanyahu personally goes, that in other words he leaves politics. And a scenario in which that could happen is that he would be pardoned by the president on the basis of his retiring from politics, leaving power and then a number of the parties, and what's talked about is throwing out these most extremist parties of Smotrich and Ben-Gvir. So the more moderate pretty extreme right-wing parties, but not the craziest of them, would make a national government that would have a majority and Netanyahu would be gone. That too would be better.

I prefer the first kind of arrangement where the Arabs who are citizens and are 20% of the population and turned out in large numbers in this democratic process are respected and become part of the political outcome. But one way or another, we need Netanyahu to go. And we need to break the grip that Netanyahu and his henchmen have had on American politics, including on President Trump.

It's disgraceful. The fact that Trump went out of his way in recent days to endorse Netanyahu is disgraceful. After every terrible thing that Netanyahu has meant for the United States, including embroiling us in this horrible war in Iran, the idea that Trump goes out and says, "Yes, he must continue," shows just how awful our situation is, how we are MIGA rather than MAGA. Make Israel Great Again." It seems to be the modus operandi of our government and American people are just sick of it. We're tired of it. We don't want this anymore.

JUDGE- Can Netanyahu, I think the answer to this is yes, because he's done it in the past, bribe away members from the Eisenkot coalition by offering them plum jobs in the cabinet. Isn't that how he ended up with Smotrich and Ben-Gvir?

SACHS- Of course, he can try that. Or another way that could be and in fact is deemed to be the likely way by many pundits today, is that no government will form and under Israeli rules that means that Netanyahu would continue as the caretaker prime minister. No doubt in a few days we would then have an explosion of new war in Iran because Trump, being under the control it seems of Netanyahu would follow through on what will turn out to be a total disaster for the United States and the world. But that is a scenario that is quite plausible. If it happens, of course, it's I think just putting Israel closer to its own doom because all of this has poisoned the world's attitude to Israel understandably so. Israel is really, objectively speaking, the most despised country in the whole world which is ironic because, you know, in the biblical or prophetic terms, Israel thought of itself as the light onto the nations, and it is the darkness onto the nations right now.

It's despised worldwide but it is despised in the United States itself. We have especially young people in the United States, population under the age of say 35, and all the opinion surveys overwhelmingly sympathetic to the Palestinians, who have been mass-murdered and really aghast at Israel. Older people remember a different Israel from the Israel we have now, because the Israeli state was not always like this. And so older people still have a different idea of Israel. But young people who are experiencing Israel for the first time are absolutely shocked. I'm just looking at one bit of the data that for 18 to 34 year olds in a recent poll, 53% supported the Palestinians, 23% Israel, if I have that data correct, these are Americans, yes young people in America, are on the Palestinian side, of course, because they've watched mass murder and they find it revolting.

JUDGE- As you think, by the way, why do you think Netanyahu and Trump have been advertising their plans to attack Iran as soon as a week from today? I mean, as soon as the American midterms are over, it's a little hard to understand, Mr. Trump.

SACHS- He has gotten us into a mess. The mess gets worse and worse. Advertising the next steps has brought opprobrium upon the United States because after all, Trump said, as we've discussed in the, well of the podium of the UN General Assembly to world leaders, that "I'm thinking about annihilating the Iranian people," sending them to hell. So the announcements have of course, given weeks of time for the Iranian military to prepare for this. And every commentator that you speak with and that I speak with and that we listen to describes all of the activity, preparatory activity, that is going on in Iran. They are not naive that it's likely that Netanyahu and Trump will try to restart the war and perhaps in a devastating way that would be a world calamity. So yes, why would you advertise this?

Absolutely no reason, especially since Trump is likely to face the wrath of the American people at the polls next week and that will be a repudiation of Trump's policies. Again, in a recent Pew survey, 65% of Americans are against the Iran war and think that Trump has completely mishandled the situation. And we'll see what happens at the polls next week, but it is likely that the American voters will repudiate Trump's policies. And then if he continues, he exposes the tragic nature of our politics now, where politicians think they don't have to listen to the people that they represent. And for Trump, of course, it's a double shame and double tragedy because what Trump is doing is precisely the opposite of what he promised in 2024 that got him elected. He said, "I'm not going to do these forever wars." And that's what made him popular among people who said yes, pay attention to America, not to BiBi and these extremist Israelis in their wars. And then Trump turned around on his own base and did exactly the opposite of what he promised. And we're all suffering the consequences. And then like you say, he advertises that he's going to double down on this after the elections that are likely to repudiate exactly this policy.

JUDGE- Can Israel survive even with American military defenses, a massive retaliation from Iran?

SACHS- We suspect that everybody's air defenses in this world are pretty much depleted by the Ukraine war which it now has been going on for well over four years, for four and a half years, at this intense rate, and by the war in Iran and by Gaza and by the wars in Israel's neighborhood that Israel has been promoting in Syria and in Lebanon.

A lot of the defense shield has been depleted. And Iran has lots of missiles and lots of hypersonic missiles that according to Ted Postal and others would get through even if they did have the anti-missile defenses which they no longer have. So the chance of tremendous devastation is real. This is tragic. This is why this fighting should stop now. But it's also terrifying because Israel is a nuclear power run by people who are thoroughly and utterly irresponsible and radical and god forbid they should escalate to nuclear war which is not impossible and is actually discussed as we know, as one possibility of what could happen with the another round of escalation. JUDGE- Before we finish today, I want to ask your opinion on the attitude of European elites toward Russia. I think I know what your opinion is, but I'd like you to be animated by this statement. I I'll leave out the adjectives.

SACHS- Yes.

JUDGE- from the UK defense minister asking the public to be prepared for war. Watch this, Professor Sachs. Chris, number one:

Wes Streeting, in video- "... it's about saying to households across the country to be ready by just having some everyday essentials indoors. So should there be disruption from those sorts of events, you're ready. Now that's things like 2 L of water per, 3 L of water per person per day. Tin goods in the cupboard to last you a few days. Things that don't necessarily need heating up in the stove or the microwave. Tined goods. If you've got babies, things like your baby food and nappy supplies, pets: pet food, water, and then things like torches that are battery powered, mobile phone charging packs. Do you have enough cash indoors if the local payment systems were down, those sorts of things that we can all do, to do our bit to be ready for everyday acts of nature. But as I said today in response to questions at my speech in Telford, there are also state-backed actors and terrorists who wish to do our country harm and are looking to do that by disrupting life for ordinary citizens."

JUDGE- Now, how do you read a statement that sounds, with the exception of microwaves and charging mobile phones, almost like Churchill during the Blitz?

SACHS- Well, my first reaction was that it's a Monty Python skit. [laughter] because...

JUDGE- Chris assures me it's not AI.

SACHS- Okay. Well, I was, that was my second impression, that this is an AI spoof of the defense minister. Britain has what I call a phantom empire syndrome. You know, people who tragically lose a limb have a phantom limb syndrome. Britain lost an empire and it still thinks it's the imperial power. I don't know whether the defense minister was referring to 1914 or whether he was referring to 1940. I'm not clear in my mind, but this is obviously bewildering in its foolishness and recklessness. I was in Britain actually the last two days. I had the opportunity to speak at a couple of universities and to meet a number of people and I also gave a media interview. You know the public is sick of this. They actually want peace in Ukraine. They're fed this line non-stop, maybe by MI6 just like the Americans have been fed this line, but the Europeans are in a Russophobic crazed state of mind that was just exemplified in this utterly bewildering little segment. But this is not the attitude of the public. The good news, Judge, is that most people everywhere actually want peace in Europe. They don't follow their chancellor in Germany. He's got a disappearing approval rating. They don't follow their president in France, another warmonger. They don't follow their multiple prime ministers in Britain who have beat the drums of war.

And each one lasts a few months, maybe a year. I think they take their marching orders from MI6, that's RCI, that's their equivalent of our CIA, and they come out with this extraordinarily Russophobic hard line, even though the opportunity actually to settle these wars peacefully at the negotiating table are rather obvious. And I'll just say that there is a glimmer of positive news which is that the prime minister of Norway and the president of Finland together spoke with President Putin in the last couple of days. Before that they had met actually with the US envoys, with Witkoff and they met with Zelensky, but there is an undercurrent of actual diplomacy starting. Europe is in such a bizarre state of mind that when there was this call from the Norwegian and Finnish leader to President Putin that went on for a reported 90 minutes, other leaders in Europe berated their counterparts for having made this call. But many I'm sure actually behind the scenes, are rather relieved that some diplomacy is starting to peek through because what has been underway is just an escalating fervor. Yes. Put your tins and your water, collect your water because we're going to war. By the way, you know, it's as you point out, it's the wrong war. Nuclear war doesn't take many days. It's a couple of hours and everybody's dead. So this whole approach is mind-boggling.

What we need to do is sit at the negotiating table. I by the way have, we've discussed it. I put forward a plan that I know is actually being read in Berlin. It's of interest in Moscow. It's not that it's my plan, but the basic point is rather than the rhetoric of escalation, rather than the idea, yes, prepare for disaster, you can actually write down very reasonably, a way for this war to end that meets the needs of Ukraine, of Russia, and of Europe. And it's actually rather straightforward to do that. So, it's not a huge mystery how this war could end.

JUDGE- I don't want to burst your bubble on the revival of some diplomacy, but here is the American version of what the UK defense minister said. Hegseth in front of George C. Scott-style American flag. Chris cut number two:

Hegseth in video- "Today at my direction, we are launching Fortress America, a national insurance policy for the American homeland. Now, Fortress stands for Federal Operations for Resilience, Troop Resources, Energy Supply, and Survivability. And here's what Fortress calls for. Every major military installation in America is going to generate its own power independent of the civilian grid.
If an adversary takes down the grid by cyber attack, by sabotage, or by any means, our bases stay lit. Our aircraft keep flying. Our command centers never go dark. We're bringing our critical supply chains home. The rare earths, the specialty metals, the semiconductors, the propellants mined in America, refined in America, built in America by American workers. We are building long overdue strategic reserves."

SACHS- Come on. This is absolutely SNL cold open. Yes. No, this is, and it actually looks like Hegseth.

JUDGE- Yeah, that [laughter] was that was Hegseth. Somehow the rare earths that are in China are going to somehow show up in American Earth. The Pentagon plans for 90 days off-grid. This is a similar subliminal threat to the American public that this UK defense minister issued to the British public.

SACHS- All I can say is the political class of Europe and the United States is making a race, not an arms race, it's a race to zero of public approval. Who can get to zero first? Nobody wants what's on offer right now from Mr. Hegseth or from President Trump in Iran war or from that very entertaining defense minister of Britain or from Germany or from France. Nobody wants this. And every person knows there's a smarter way to do this than 90 days off-grid. No thank you. Let's not have World War III again, sad to say for all of these genius planners, doesn't take 90 days to end humanity anymore. And so all their wonderful plans are total, total nonsense. Why don't we have some diplomacy?

JUDGE- Professor Sachs, thank you very much. I know it's practically tomorrow where you are, but thank you for your time as always. We look forward to seeing you next week.

SACHS- Excellent. Wonderful. Thanks a lot.

JUDGE- Bye-bye.

§

Jeffrey Sachs: "As Long as It Takes For What?" – Busting the Ukraine War Propaganda - The Peacemonger - Ian Proud, Oct 28, 2026

IAN- Professor Jeffrey Sachs, welcome to London.

SACHS- Ah, so good to be with you. I'm delighted.

IAN- So, you have a plan, a peace plan. You've circulated it. Lots of people are talking about it. Why don't you briefly introduce us to it?

SACHS- Basically, this war never should have happened. The war in Ukraine was caused by a 30-year US campaign to surround Russia with NATO military bases. and the US knew what it was doing and Brzeziński, Zbigniew Brzeziński, in the 1990s, who described what this would be, said Russia will have to give in, they didn't expect a war, they just expected that NATO would enlarge, it would enlarge first to central Europe - Hungary, Poland, Czech Republic, then in 2004 it did enlarge - the Baltic states, Romania, Bulgaria, Slovakia, Slovenia - so seven more countries. And then in 2008, they said, "Okay, now we surround Russia in the Black Sea." I call it the Palmerston strategy because it's the same as 1853.

It's the Crimean War once again. We're going to have Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria, Turkey, and Georgia in a pincer around Russia. This was the plan. The whole idea Brzeziński explained in 1997, is that Ukraine is what he called a "geopolitical pivot." It is on our chessboard. That's our pawn. We move that. Russia's trapped. He said it all. And he said Russia can't resist. We're so powerful economically, financially, technologically, militarily. What can Russia do except go along with it? So this is a war that came from an absolute, deliberate, consciously planned idea of expanding the American empire eastward.

Of course the Brits would say it's the British-American Empire. Okay. The Germans might say, "Hey, we have something to do with this. We're the powerful country of Europe." But all of the three main actors, the US, the UK and Germany, said, "We move eastward. What can Russia do?" The Russians, as you know, but I know it from my experience already back 36 years, said, "Don't do that. Stop. Don't do that. You promised us, and I could give you the date and the place you promised us." For example, February 10th, 1990. Helmut Kohl, speaking directly with President Gorbachev: "We will not move NATO eastward." My Secretary of State James Baker III, February 9th to Gorbachev, "we will not move one inch eastward." That's where that expression comes from. Hans Dietrich Genscher, the German foreign minister on January 31st, 1990 at the famous Tutzing Cathedral address, "we will not take advantage of the Soviet Union, of the weakness economically, of the end of the Soviet military presence and alliance in Eastern Europe, we will not move eastward." Ah, all a bunch of lies after 1992.

Putin told us, "Don't do this." Our own CIA director when he was ambassador to Russia, Mr. Burns - "Don't do this. This is a red line, not just of Mr. Putin, of the entire Russian political class." Frankly, I don't blame them. I don't blame them because if Russia opened a military base in Mexico, the Americans wouldn't say, "Well, that's Mexico's issue. We don't care." We made a Monroe doctrine 203 years ago in 1823 which said to the Europeans not only don't come to our border, don't even come to anywhere in our hemisphere. That was the Monroe Doctrine. So if we just had a little bit of Golden Rule, don't do to them what we don't want them to do to us, this war never would have happened. My peace plan is therefore extremely straightforward. Remove the underlying cause of this war. Just have Ukraine go back to what it declared in 1990, what it was implementing in the 2010s before the West conspired to overthrow Mr. Yanukovych, which is neutrality. Go back to the truth. Don't move NATO to Russia's borders. Are we out of our minds? Do we really want to provoke a nuclear war? Is that really our idea? Do we want to do to them what we would never accept them doing to us? Well, apparently some people in Britain feel that way. Some people in the United States feel that way. It's crazy. Stop the NATO enlargement.

I say in my plan that Ukraine should have a path as a candidate to become a member of the European Union and Russia should be explicit. Yes, they're a candidate, but under two conditions - one, they're a candidate to join the EU, not as a military alliance, but as a neutral country that becomes part of the European a key communitar, so-called, of the economy, but not of a military alliance and the EU-27 hosts neutral countries, so it's not unusual. Let them join as a neutral country and the last point, Ian, is maybe seemingly the toughest, but I don't even think it's the toughest. Stop the fighting on some line.

I don't know where that line is going to be, by the way, in two weeks, four weeks, eight weeks. But my point is an armistice line that says because I think it's sad to say, inevitable. This is a line - on this side, it's Russian administration, on this side it's Ukrainian administration.

Both sides agree. No more fighting over that. They may disagree completely on who legally should control what territory. So not a juridical line, but the kind of line that ended the Korean War and many other conflicts, which is just a line drawn. This is how it is practically. We don't necessarily accept it juridically, the Russians will say that's unacceptable. We demand recognition. These are our territories. They're part of our constitution. Of course, the Ukrainians will say, "We will never accept Russia having that, our constitution says, our 1991 lines." Well, we could fight over that until we blow up the whole world or until every Ukrainian dies. Or we could say, practically speaking, we're stopping. The war is ending. There's an armistice.

We don't give juridical answers on either side, but we give a practical answer. And the key practical points are two. Administrative control and no more fighting over that issue. But diplomacy, fine. You could have referenda. You could have all sorts of things. You could have UN blah, blah, blah, but whatever. I don't mean it blah, blah, blah, in a, you know, dismissive way. But what I do mean is we're going to do that peacefully, not by war. So that's the four-point plan. It's not unlike what was on the table in Istanbul in April 2022. It's not quite as good because Russia's advanced on the front lines, but it's not unlike what Ukraine was about to sign at the time that we remember Boris Johnson swooping into his famous trip in May of 2022 to tell the Ukrainians, "You fight on, we have your back," probably a million dead and wounded or more since that moment for no reason except losing more ground. But they were going to sign an agreement on this basis. So that's my idea. Neutrality, no NATO, an end to NATO enlargement, which is just going back to the promise that was actually made. The third is a pathway to EU membership.

I have to footnote that many EU countries don't want Ukraine in. So, I'm not saying that it becomes a member. I'm just saying it becomes a candidate. Let them solve it. That's not my business. And fourth, an armistice. An armistice line, de facto jurisdiction, not de jure settlement because to get to de jure settlement could take years or it could take never or it could take whatever.

But it's not necessary to stop the killing, stop the fighting, stop the risk of nuclear escalation. I've shared that with the Russians. I've shared that with the Americans. I mean, the Russians - I've sent it to some Russian officials. I've sent it to some American officials. I've sent it to some European officials. I posted it online. I've made it available. Of course, I'm not saying this is your plan. But what I am saying to the Europeans in particular is have a plan. Stop using empty slogans. Stop saying we stand with the Ukrainians as long as it takes. Well, excuse me. As long as it takes - For what? For what? They don't say that.

They're cheating and they know it. They don't want to say it. Or they say, "We have to fight until Russia loses." Loses. What does that mean? Does that mean, oh, we go all the way to a nuclear war? Or you think Russia's going to put down its arms because Ukraine has won militarily? Are you kidding? So I want the Europeans actually, British included in that grouping, to actually start speaking adult language even to the public, even to us as citizens to say what do you mean?

Do you mean that we're really fighting, fighting until the 1991 borders are reestablished? Is that what you mean? Do you mean that NATO must expand to Ukraine if Ukraine wants it? Because NATO has an open door, an idea, I will repeat that is anathema to the United States if applied to itself. So it really is the British-American idea that we do what we want, but they must not do what we do.

Is that the idea? Tell us. If you tell us certain things we'll say you're fools because all you're doing is putting our lives at risk. What I really resent, they're putting my grandchildren's lives at risk. I really, really resent that.

So, I want Europeans to speak like grown-ups again, which they don't do. I want them to move beyond vacuity, beyond slogans, beyond "as long as it takes," beyond "we stand with Ukraine," "beyond Russia must lose." I want them to say how this war can end. But most importantly, I want them to sit with the Russians.

You know why? Because our side lies so much about what happened and you know the Russians very well, and I've dealt with the Russians for 36 years. They will tell you that's a lie and here's why. And then you have to answer face to face and you say okay, okay, Mr. Sergey, you're right. You're right. We should acknowledge that that was said. Once you do that, you start acting in a different way. Just not hugging Zelensky for the 10,000th time in this absolute embrace of death, by the way, cuz all you're telling them is you keep fighting and dying, and when you run out of men, send the women to fight and die, and here's some more money for you, that's coming out of NHS and whatever. You might actually have to confront some truths and the truths could actually lead, truths could lead to truths. It could lead to the end of fighting once you have to go face to face. They're really smart. The Russians, you know, Lavrov, I know Lavrov for more than 30 years. He's in my view one of the finest foreign ministers in the whole world, and his mind, he knows everything that's happened. So let him tell you this is what happened. This is what you said. This is what was promised. What happened to Minsk II? What happened to your promises to us? Okay. You have to then answer that.

Then you start saying, okay let's find a way to end this thing so that you're safe, we're safe, Ukraine is safe. That's the idea.

IAN- Yeah. One of the advantages of not doing diplomacy is that you don't have to face up to your adversary and hear directly from them. Exactly. Their concerns. You can live in this world of generalized slogans and tropes and media propaganda. Støre and Stubb have now spoken to Putin which has been met with already criticism.

SACHS- Sure. Scandal. Yes. And by the way, I know both of them and I greatly admire them for doing this and I have wanted them to do this. Of course, I've wanted Merz to do this. I've wanted your prime minister to do it. Whichever one it is, they keep coming. The reason that Britain can't keep a prime minister for more than a few months is that they are devoting all of Britain's scarce budget and scarce resources to a war rather than to the needs of the British people. So they keep coming, they keep going, they keep losing any public support. If your prime minister would say, and especially this one, by the way, "I was a mayor. I know what it's like in the communities. We need to solve our problems." That would be wonderful. Instead, I'm fearful that when the budget comes out, your chancellor is going to say, "We have to tighten our belts because we must support Ukraine for the world's safety." And suddenly there's more budget squeeze. And I don't think your prime minister will last long in that way because what the people in this country want actually is to have the needs of this country fulfilled. And if you can do it by a diplomatic solution, good. By the way, naturally, especially in this country, oh appeasement, this, that I'm not talking about appeasement at all. I'm talking about an arrangement which leaves Europe safe, which leaves Ukraine safe, and which meets legitimate security needs of Russia. And I would hate anyone to sign that document and then declare peace for our time. No, I would like them to sign a document, say we must be vigilant. We must be careful. We will monitor. We will be safe. We are not naive. We don't believe signing a document is the end of a story, but it could be the beginning of a peace. So, we're going to try this, but we're going to remain vigilant.

That's the attitude I think that should be used. Not to say we can't trust the other side, therefore, war is inevitable and we must prepare and go stock up. There may be shortages of water and food, so you can't be too careful with the war coming. Are you kidding? We're actually hearing that.

IAN- Yes. Yeah, we're hearing that.

SACHS- Yes, we're hearing this literally. Are you kidding? You don't need to stock up. Nuclear war is very fast. It, you know, it's not going to take months and years. It's going to take a few minutes and we're all going to be gone. So, just stop this idea. Stop the rhetoric. Stop the craziness. Sit down and talk. And yes, when you have an agreement, think hard. Is this enforceable? Is this mutually beneficial? Does this suit Britain's needs, Europe's needs, Ukraine's needs, Russia's needs? That is an idea, by the way, enshrined in the Helsinki Final Act. It's enshrined in the Treaty of Paris in 1990. It's enshrined in countless documents of the Organization of Security and Cooperation of Europe. It's called "indivisible security." That's the basis. You honestly say, "We're concerned about our security, but we admit that they are concerned about their security, too." Shocking idea. Yeah. But it's the point.

IAN- It's exactly right. Have you approached the British government? Have they responded to your efforts to sort of perhaps engage with them directly?

SACHS- I haven't really done that properly. But I will be very happy to share any ideas. I would, you know, you have an intelligent foreign minister and so that's a good start. I'm shocked by the rhetoric. I really like your prime minister for everything I know. I don't know him personally. I like a good mayor, by the way, because a mayor really knows what the country needs because they've lived it. They've been on the front line of the domestic needs, of the housing needs, of the public transport needs, of the NHS needs, of the school needs. Wonderful. Perfect. Don't get involved in an extended war, break the budget, spend what is all over the Western world, a budget crisis right now, A real fiscal crisis, by the way. We have it in the United States. You have it here. It's true in all in the EU-27. Everyone is at a breaking point. And Merz says, "Well, we must tighten our belts to go to war." And his approval rating is 10% or less. His party can't even get a seat in a Lander Parliament.

They can't even make the 4% cut-off anymore because people are disgusted by this. They actually want to live their normal lives. So when we see the budget here, I'm hoping someone has some sense. Meet the needs of the British people, please.

IAN- Exactly. A friend of mine, Commodore Steve Jermy, ex-Royal Navy, he started a petition calling for a referendum. It seems to me that what we don't have enough is conversations with ordinary British people about what they want because there's such a media blackout in this country. I mean, you've just been speaking to Times Radio. Yeah. Just before...

SACHS- Well, it wasn't a blackout. They let me speak. I think it was a little shocking for some of the listeners because they were, you know, and to their credit, they had me on, but I think the presenter said, you know, this is not the view here. I said yes because people don't hear that view at all. And I know in the United States, you know, you've felt it. But for me, I have been absolutely barred from the mainstream media on this issue. They won't print 700 words in the New York Times for the last four years.

They used to print anything I wrote. You know, of course, it had to be okay, but they would print op-eds and be very happy. Same with the Financial Times. Impossible, because everyone wants just a narrow permissible band of discussion. You go outside it, you're a Putin apologist. You're a - It's absurd. And for me, it's completely absurd. When Ukraine became independent, I became one of their first external advisers. I volunteered my time, by the way, as I always do. I'm not a paid consultant when I work with governments. I do it on my academic salary. I've been doing that for 41 years since I started working in Bolivia. And I did it so that no one could say you're just a paid hack. I'm not a paid hack. I'm someone trying to help. I wanted to help Ukraine from the start. I wanted to help the Baltic States from the start. I have a national award, one of the highest civilian awards they give from the president of Estonia because I helped them design their central bank in 1992. And you know who was the central bank governor? Siim Kallas, the father of Kaja Kallas. And it's very interesting for me because she won't meet with me, but I helped her father make a successful currency and design the central bank. So, I'm not anyone's apologist. I just know that we could have peace because peace was on the table. But instead of taking peace, our side says, "We don't want peace. We want victory. We want hegemony. We want control." Brzeziński spells it all out.

Not just him, all the neocons that completely took over and the Deep State, which in our case is the CIA, they've been at this for a very long time. I don't think they're giving up to this moment. Actually, Trump, I don't think he's interested in any of this. But I think the CIA probably still is, "we got to defeat the Russians. We have to break them apart. We have to divide them. We have to surround them." I have a feeling that institutionally they're still on that line. Even though I don't think our president, who is not a great strategist, I have to say, I don't think he's interested in any of that.

Our permanent state probably still is on the same line they've been on for 36 years. They just thought it wouldn't lead to war. They just thought it would lead to American primacy, was the word that they used, and that Russia could never resist it.

IAN- Sadly, my impression for them, at least not for the Russians, is that the Russian state is holding up remarkably well having just been, and you know, the only way out of this is dialogue. To me that it's developed so much, the country, I was surprised wondering what I'd see when I when I got back. But what's absolutely clear was that even in the corridors people make kind of, you know, say funny comments about the internal politics of Russia. People are absolutely behind the Russian position on this. I saw no real kind of cracks there. So the sooner we can get around the table, talk peace, the sooner we can bring this to an end.

SACHS- And by the way, Ian, one of the strangest things, I'm an economist, so I watch this quite closely. Europe has put on 22 rounds of sanctions right now. Every one of this is tightening the noose around the European economy.

IAN- Yeah,

SACHS- It's crazy. You do that one more time, I'll strangle myself even more because this has broken the European economy.

It's broken the back of the German industry, which isn't just the German industry, it's the whole central European industry.

And I was there helping to bring Central Europe, Hungary, Poland, Czech Republic, and so forth into the fold.

And I saw, of course, was the strength of the German economy that I counted on to help lift these countries and also to help Germany because they would invest. And I believe Germany and Russia would make a great economic combination, which of course the United States was always terrified about.

But Britain's part of this story. If you cut yourself off from a major trading partner, if you suffer soaring energy prices, what do you think's going to happen to your industry? And then if you go on because the United States said, we must be hegemon, we must be have primacy. China's a danger. You start cutting yourself off from Chinese trade as well. In the end, you end up with stagnation with decline. And then if your great friend, my country, weird place, suddenly attacks Iran on a on February 28th of this year and drives world oil prices up to $110 a barrel, maybe it'll be $120. Maybe it'll be $150 by the time Donald Trump gets done with this. What do you think's going to happen to the economy? And then if you listen to this craziness, sorry, of Mr. Trump and Mr. Hegseth, your allies, well, you need to spend 5% of GDP on NATO. My god. Okay. Does everyone have to go broke? This is what comes out.

IAN- The only time when sanctions and this final comment - I need to dash off to LSC. The only time when the Russian economy was under significant pressure was between 2014 and 2016. That was when the sanctions first came in. That was when the oil price suffered two dips in 2014 and in January 2016. I was in Moscow at the time. I was watching this all unfold. Since that time, they've completely reoriented their monetary and fiscal policy to deal with it. They've embraced a weak ruble. Even as people like Biden were saying, "We'll turn the ruble to rubble." The Russians love turning the ruble to rubble because it massively increases the ruble value of every barrel of oil sold. Absolutely. And by the way, they fundamentally reoriented trade with Asia.

IAN- Yeah.

SACHS- And it works.

IAN- And we're now in a period of unprecedented, not unprecedented, but very high, global energy prices. Russia is exactly maximizing the benefit from this. And nobody can see it.

SACHS- Exactly. Crazy, crazy stuff. Thank you for, you know, your voice of sanity here, which is so important and it's heard worldwide. So not only here, but let's hope that some grown-ups in this region in Europe, in Britain, just would say we got to get off this, we got to get off this crazy war drive before real total disaster hits.

IAN- Let's hope for that. Let's hope for peace. First, Jeffrey Sachs, what a pleasure.

SACHS- Good things.

IAN- Pleasure is more mine.

§

8th Gas Exporting Countries Forum

The 8th Gas Exporting Countries Forum was held at the World Trade Center (the real one) in Moscow. The full text of the Plenary Session can be found at the Kremlin web site and the full video presentation here. In attendance were Russia, Qatar, Algeria, Malaysia, Iran (President and Foreign Minister), Iraq, South Africa, Egypt, UAE, (some Arabic name), Peru, Mozambique, Venezuela, Nigeria, Angola, Libya, Equatorial New Guinea, Algeria, of the labels I could read. Notably missing, of course, are the "Like-minded" vassal-states, participating in these market-making discussions would be beneath them.


Leave a comment! This is a re-direct to my Substack page.

Return to Limits to Progress Main Page

If you would like to send a donation, please send an Interac eTransfer to email address below. Thank you!

©2026 Kathleen McCroskey

Send your e-mail comments and questions to:
Mail page