A long comment thread from Glenn Diesen's Substack:


(Diplomacy could look like this)

Alicja (direct comment to Glenn Diesen's post): A few questions in regard to Russia's concern about NATO being at their "doorstep". If Ukraine collapses, are NATO members (and neighbors) Poland and Finland next? Or perhaps it's simply former Soviet countries such as Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania that are the next targets because of their sovereign right to self determination? When and where does Russia stop?
The "NATO at Russia's doorstep" argument doesn't hold up when these questions are asked and Ukraine comes into view merely as a strategic landmass Russia wants full control over.
Kathleen McCroskey: Ukraine and Iran were deemed "Pivot States" already in 1997 in Brzezinski's book Grand Bargain, as keys to conquering Asia. After the Maidan coup of 2014, US and MI6 kept prodding the Kyiv regime to repeatedly bomb and shell IT'S CITIZENS in SE Ukraine until Russia came to their assistance (as the people requested). Russia is NOT interested in any part of Europe, they simply want a zone of security around their land, same as U.S. does. It is no cause for any difficulty for nations along Russia's (and China's) border to be actually neutral. This theme of "Russian aggression" is entirely propaganda for EU's desired war against Russia, their desire to conquer and break it up. THOSE are the aggressors!
Alicja: Thank you for your response, I accept it with great consideration.
The events which culminated in "the Maidan coup" have been extensively documented and investigated, resulting in charges filed against both (Russia) FSB officers and (Ukraine) SBU employees for their joint participation. However what transpired after, I'm not privy to CIA, MI6 or any country's intelligence agencies' operations. To make such a claim is nothing more than conjecture.
In regard to Brzezinski's book, The Grand Chessboard, anyone with a reasonable understanding of geopolitics, can easily summarize it as outdated and of a bygone era. Too many variables have changed and therefore should be taken only as leisurely reading material. I can't imagine any serious world leader using that book as a reference or guide to foreign policy. As for the argument that countries require neutral buffers; that simply does not exist, except for countries waging war against their neighbors or against different factions within their country. For example: The demilitarized zone between North and South Korea. The Iraq war with Kuwait and within Iraq with the Kurds. Throughout the world, sovereign nations reside next to each other - like Canada, the USA, Mexico, Guatemala, Belize etc.
Per Dørup (reply to Alicja): Oh no, Brezinskis book: The Grand Chessboard, 1997, is not obsolete, but guiding US imperialist policy. And no, the Maidan coup is not conjecture. There's lot of photo documentation on the Internet showing people with nazi emblems on their shoulders in the front.
And it was not for nothing that Hillary Clinton up to 2014 invested about 6 billion dollar in an regime change operation.
Alicja (reply to Per): Conjecture is whether there was CIA and MI6 involvement after because I am not privy to government clandestine operations. Please read before commenting.
Your proof of Nazis are pictures on the internet of people wearing the Nazi emblem. Have you ever been to or seen pictures of a Trump rally? I suppose the same logic applies. Then, who will save America from its Nazification? This $6m: https://www.factcheck.org/2019/10/headlines-spin-ukrainian-donations-to-clinton-charity/
Kathleen McCroskey: The Korean DMZ is a small strip of land, neither country is neutral, S. Korea is a fine example of US arming up a neighbor against one it hates. There are only 3 sovereign nations: China, Iran, Russia. Mexico and Canada are captive vassals. What would US do if Russia put missiles in Mexico? Refer to "Cuban missile 'crisis'" NATO became an offensive alliance t break up Russia, that is their long-standing goal. And what Europe is not seeing is the after the 1990s, U.S. stage-managed WW-III to be fought on European soil rather than the Russia/US nuclear stalemate of the Cold War. Yes, the West prodding Kyiv to kill its own people in Donbas is MY conjecture, by deep analysis, and it follows from the same playbook as US baiting Russia to invade Afghanistan. It causes no nation any pain whatsoever to be non-aligned alongside one of the major powers.
Alicja: Please understand, I am not defending the U.S. in any way. Their mask of moral authority and beacon of democracy slipped decades ago. My main concern is Russia's neighbor, Finland.
Kathleen McCroskey: Finland has nothing to fear except fear itself. "Arming up" is not the answer, dialogue is, but that is impossible if a nation has been overcome with Hate, which abolishes any prospect of Trust on which diplomacy depends.
Lorna Hillman: So correct. Finland's biggest mistake was ending its neutrality and allowing the US to put a nuclear base on its territory. I used to think the Finns were smarter than that. Clearly this generation of Finnish politicians have amnesia when it comes to their own diplomatic history after WW2.
Kathleen McCroskey (To Alicja): These Scandinavian countries got caught up in pro-NATO hysteria following the Ukraine situation and signed up. Many people there are locked into pro-NATO ideology (I've lost some subscribers that way), but there are exceptions such as Glenn Diesen, but those madly rushing to war won the day.
Alicja: Finland and Russia/USSR have had a long and complex relationship. Finland is a NATO member and upon joining Russia warned there would be major political and military consequences which would threaten stability in the Nordic region. That does not sound like a peaceful neighbor but rather one who is egomaniacal and prone to paranoia.
As the U.S. is learning, once purported "vassal states" - as you put it, are no longer bowing to their unreasonable demands. Sovereign nations will fight for their right of self-determination, whether Russia or the U.S. for that matter, agrees or not.
Kathleen McCroskey: Yes, well, that's the problem, joining NATO. After the Cold War there was another treaty arrangement making NATO an offensive alliance, and Russia warned the West for decades not to push NATO bases right up to its borders - in fact, it was part of the 2 + 4 Treaty finally ending WW-II which allowed German reunification, that the West agreed, as part of that, not to push NATO "one inch farther East." Which lasted how many minutes? So, ignoring all that history, Finland joins NATO? Now U.S. bases can be along the Finnish border now too? This is not threatening to Russia? The hegemonic and paranoid Empire resides on the NATO side, not on the Russian side. All else is merely projection. Russia and China insist on UN Charter rules, why not go with that? NATO was set up as an end-run around the UN, because the U.S. CANNOT sit around a table treating other nations as equals, it MUST sit at the head of the table, in charge of all. That is why they set up NATO, they can't stand being just another vote at UN. And to facilitate initiation of NATO, they commandeered funds appropriated for the Korean War to essentially bribe European leaders and media to get them into NATO. Finland could again be in peace by exiting NATO and engage in neighborly relations with their neighbor, Russia, rather than living in fear and pointing guns across their border. This step toward war is a step away from Peace.
Alicja: Kathleen, I've really enjoyed our discussion. Although we may disagree on some aspects of foreign affairs and cross-border policies (due to individually lived experiences and history), your insight, viewpoint and concerns are nonetheless valid. Thank you for your time responding.
Kathleen McCroskey: Thank you, Alicja, for participating in a long discussion! This is how discussions across every border should carry on - the most basic level is Respect, from which can come trust and dialogue. The first goal in a discussion between nations, is that yes, we have a relationship, and we start by saying this is a good relationship because we can talk, then let's move every other possible source of friction off the "relationship" level, onto some lower level of discussion. When nations let one small disagreement sever the talk at relationship level, getting to Peace becomes very difficult. Thus Finland's goal should be to take any hate of Russia off the relationship level, again call for being good neighbors to each other, while learning how to practice actual neutrality, which respects your own sovereignty. https://kathleenmccroskey.substack.com/p/sovereignty-vs-neutrality

Leave a comment! This is a re-direct to my Substack page.

Return to Limits to Progress Main Page

If you would like to send a donation, please send an Interac eTransfer to email address below. Thank you!

©2026 Kathleen McCroskey

Send your e-mail comments and questions to:
Mail page